Using data from three trials of FMT plus anti-PD-1 in melanoma, Fessler et al. performed a strain-resolved metagenomic meta-analysis, and found that while neither microbial diversity nor acquisition of specific bacterial species were associated with response, recipient acquisition of the donor microbiome and microbiome community stability were. Further, while non-responders were enriched for pro-inflammatory and pathogen-associated secretion system genes, responders were enriched for functions of community-level metabolism and communication, highlighting the importance of the microbial ecosystem over species richness or specific species.
Contributed by Lauren Hitchings
ABSTRACT: Fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) has shown promise in improving anti-PD-1 therapy in melanoma, but the underlying microbial features remain poorly defined. We performed a strain-resolved metagenomic meta-analysis across three independent FMT plus anti-PD-1 melanoma trials (n_=_41). Across cohorts, therapeutic benefit was linked to successful integration of donor microbiota, rather than increased diversity or engraftment of specific species. Responders acquired more donor-derived strains, exhibited greater post-FMT similarity to their donor, and maintained a more stable microbiome. Following FMT, non-responders' microbiomes showed greater taxonomic instability, larger fluctuations in estimated microbial load, and increased abundance of pathogen-associated secretion system genes, whereas responders showed enrichment for microbial functions involved in community-level metabolism and communication. Finally, shifts in tumor-infiltrating immune profiles tracked with clinical outcomes and microbiome changes. Together these findings highlight that distinct patterns of microbiome restructuring, including stable community transitions and altered functional capacity, are associated with anti-PD-1 response following FMT.
