Using a CMV-epitope-expressing transplanted tumor in transgenic immune tolerant mice that express CMV epitopes in pancreatic islet cells, Sultan et al. show that a highly effective CMV-based vaccine can overcome tolerance and induce potent anti-tumor activity but also induce severe diabetogenic symptoms. Boosting immunization with a agonist-CD40 antibody generated T cells sensitive to negative signaling via the PD-1 axis, which was not observed when immunization was boosted with long-lived IL-2.
Immunotherapy has shown a tremendous success in treating cancer. Unfortunately, this success is frequently associated with severe autoimmune pathology. In this study, we used the transgenic RIP-gp mouse model to assess the antitumor therapeutic benefit of peptide vaccination while evaluating the possible associated autoimmune pathology. We report that palmitoylated gp33-41 peptide and poly-IC adjuvant vaccine (BiVax) generated approximately 5-10 % of antigen specific T cell responses in wild type and supposedly immune tolerant RIP-gp mice. Boosting with BiVax in combination with alphaCD40 antibody (TriVax) or BiVax in combination with IL-2/alphaIL-2 antibody complexes (IL2Cx) significantly increased the immune responses ( approximately 30-50%). Interestingly, although both boosts were equally effective in generating vast T cell responses, BiVax/IL2Cx showed better control of tumor growth than TriVax. However, this effect was associated with high incidence of diabetes in an antigen and CD8 dependent fashion. T cell responses generated by BiVax/IL2Cx, but not those generated by TriVax were highly resistant to PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitory signals. Nevertheless, PD-1 blockade enhanced the ability of TriVax to control tumor growth but increased the incidence of diabetes. Finally, we show that severe autoimmunity by BiVax/IL2Cx was prevented while preserving outstanding antitumor responses by utilizing a tumor antigen not expressed in the pancreas. Our data provides a clear evidence that peptide based vaccines can expand vast endogenous T cell responses which effectively control tumor growth but with high potential of autoimmune pathology.