Weekly Digests
‹ Back to July

Personalized Neoantigen Vaccines for High-risk Melanoma Patients

July 19, 2017

The ability to induce de novo, potent, and truly tumor-specific T cell responses as shown in two independent studies with different vaccine formats by Ott & Hu et al. (Ott&Hu) and Sahin et al. (Sahin) has the potential to transform cancer vaccination. T cells directed against neoantigens, which arise from non-silent somatic mutations that are unique to each patient’s tumor, are now known to be central to the mechanisms of action of modern immunotherapies. However, to capitalize on the encouraging biology of neoantigens, it is necessary to overcome the hurdles of preparing a personalized vaccine, a challenge now met by these two studies.

To generate the vaccine, both groups used whole exome and RNA sequencing to identify and validate non-synonomous single nucleotide variant mutations and predicted neoepitopes capable of binding to the patient’s individual MHC class I molecules to activate CD8+ T cells. As points of difference, Ott&Hu also included out-of-frame insertion and deletion mutations, and Sahin predicted MHC class II binding neoepitopes to stimulate CD4+ T cells in two patients.

Ott&Hu vaccinated patients with up to 20 long peptides, each covering a specific mutation and potentially capturing MHC class II neoepitopes, together with the TLR3 agonist poly-ICLC as adjuvant, subcutaneously. Sahin injected patients with two synthetic RNA molecules, each encoding five linker-connected long peptides, directly into the lymph node. By targeting multiple neoepitopes simultaneously, both studies address tumor heterogeneity and immunologic escape through antigen loss.

Both studies enrolled high-risk, stage III and IV melanoma patients. Ott&Hu treated six patients, two of whom received IFN-α as prior systemic therapy, and all of whom had no evidence of disease following surgery. Sahin treated thirteen patients, many of whom had received one or more prior systemic therapies, and 5 of whom had evidence of disease at the initiation of vaccination. Nine of the 13 patients in the Sahin study received an RNA vaccine against the tumor-associated self-antigens (TAA) NY-ESO-1 and/or tyrosinase prior to neoantigen vaccination.

Vaccination induced CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses against multiple neoepitopes in all of the treated patients. Remarkably, T cell responses were detected against 60% of the vaccinating neoepitopes. While Sahin detected weak pre-existing T cell responses for a third of the vaccine-induced responses, Ott&Hu observed only de novo responses. In both trials, a fifth of the vaccinating neoepitopes stimulated T cell responses which could be detected directly ex vivo, while the others were seen after one round of in vitro stimulation. Proportionally, more CD4+ than CD8+ neoepitope-specific T cells were induced. In each trial, two thirds of the epitopes that elicited specific CD8+ T cells also induced CD4+ T cells. T cells were found to be polyfunctional, secreting multiple effector cytokines, and effectively distinguished between wild-type and single-amino-acid-mutated antigens. Of note, Sahin reported significantly stronger T cell responses against neoepitopes compared to the shared TAAs.

Ott&Hu found that 73% of the neoantigen-reactive CD4+ cells and 100% of the CD8+ cells recognize endogenously processed and presented neoantigens on transfected B cells. Furthermore, Ott&Hu verified MHC class I and II expression on originally resected metastatic tumors, and both studies showed that neoepitope-specific CD4+ and CD8+ T cells were reactive against the patient’s own melanoma. Finally, Sahin confirmed the infiltration of vaccine-induced T cells in the cognate tumor, suggesting that neoantigen-specific T cells are effective in vivo.

The historic rate of recurrence for high-risk melanoma two years after surgery is ~50%, but the majority of vaccinated patients remained recurrence free for the follow up period of 20-32 months (4 patients of Ott&Hu) and 12-23 months (10 patients of Sahin). In each study, two patients who experienced recurrence were transitioned onto anti-PD-1 checkpoint blockade therapy. Three of these four patients experienced complete and durable tumor regression. Immune analysis 9 to 12 months later demonstrated that the repertoire of vaccine-induced T cells persisted and that additional neoantigen responses could be detected. One of the anti-PD-1 treated patients died due to outgrowth of melanoma with defective MHC class I presentation (β2-microglobulin loss).

The demonstrated feasibility of preparing a truly personalized vaccine based on each patient’s unique tumor along with the highly specific, potent immunological responses that were induced in these two early clinical trials open up a whole new approach to cancer immunotherapy.   

by Dominique Stavis and Ute Burkhardt


Sahin U., Derhovanessian E., Miller M., Kloke B.P., Simon P., Löwer M., Bukur V., Tadmor A.D., Luxemburger U., Schrörs B., Omokoko T., Vormehr M., Albrecht C., Paruzynski A., Kuhn A.N., Buck J., Heesch S., Schreeb K.H., Müller F., Ortseifer I., Vogler I., Godehardt E., Attig S., Rae R., Breitkreuz A., Tolliver C., Suchan M., Martic G., Hohberger A., Sorn P., Diekmann J., Ciesla J., Waksmann O., Brück A.K., Witt M., Zillgen M., Rothermel A., Kasemann B., Langer D., Bolte S., Diken M., Kreiter S., Nemecek R., Gebhardt C., Grabbe S., Höller C., Utikal J., Huber C., Loquai C., Türeci Ö. Personalized RNA mutanome vaccines mobilize poly-specific therapeutic immunity against cancer. Nature. 2017 Jul 13.

Ott P.A., Hu Z., Keskin D.B., Shukla S.A., Sun J., Bozym D.J., Zhang W., Luoma A., Giobbie-Hurder A., Peter L., Chen C., Olive O., Carter T.A., Li S., Lieb D.J., Eisenhaure T., Gjini E., Stevens J., Lane W.J., Javeri I., Nellaiappan K., Salazar A.M., Daley H., Seaman M., Buchbinder E.I., Yoon C.H., Harden M., Lennon N., Gabriel S., Rodig S.J., Barouch D.H., Aster J.C., Getz G., Wucherpfennig K., Neuberg D., Ritz J., Lander E.S., Fritsch E.F., Hacohen N., Wu C.J. An immunogenic personal neoantigen vaccine for patients with melanoma. Nature. 2017 Jul 13.

In the Spotlight...

Antitumor HPV E7-specific CTL activity elicited by in vivo engineered exosomes produced through DNA inoculation

Bonito et al. describe a novel vaccine platform using a mutated HIV-NEF protein to target attached antigen to the exosome pathway. A DNA vaccine encoding the construct and delivered to muscle produces exosomes containing the target antigen, induces strong T cell responses, and controls tumor growth in a therapeutic murine tumor model.

IFNgamma-Dependent Tissue-Immune Homeostasis Is Co-opted in the Tumor Microenvironment

To tease apart the balance between tolerance and immunity, Nirschl et al. examined an IFNγ-inducible 227 gene signature enriched in tissue-resident and migratory DCs that positively correlates with metastatic melanoma survival. One of the key induced transcripts (SOCS2) suppresses adaptive immune response, preserving tissue homeostasis, but potentially allowing tumor growth.

Combined immunotherapy: CTLA-4 blockade potentiates anti-tumor response induced by transcutaneous immunization

Transcutaneous immunization (TCI) of melanoma-bearing mice with the TLR7 agonist, imiquimod, and a tumor antigen-specific peptide in combination with anti-CTLA-4 increased primary and memory CD8+ T cell responses compared with TCI alone, in a Treg-independent manner. The combination therapy improved survival, but failed to completely reject the tumor.

Adoptive transfer of murine T cells expressing a chimeric-PD1-Dap10 receptor as an immunotherapy for lymphoma

Lynch et al. created a chimeric PD-1 receptor (chPD1) by replacing the inhibitory domains of PD-1 with the activating domains of CD3ζ and Dap10 or CD28. Adoptively transferred chPD1-Dap10 T cells showed superior anti-tumor efficacy in immunocompetent, lymphoma-bearing mice compared with chPD1-CD28 T cell therapy, likely due to their preferential cytokine profile and differentiation phenotype.

Metabolic Regulation of T Cell Longevity and Function in Tumor Immunotherapy

This comprehensive review by Kishton et al. covers the metabolic activity of T cells as it relates to longevity, differentiation trajectory and end state, functionality, and anti-tumor activity. It also explores the metabolic competition T cells face from other cells in the tumor microenvironment and suggests possible metabolic interventions to counter the dampening of antitumor immune responses.

Adoptively transferred Vgamma9Vdelta2 T cells show potent antitumor effects in a preclinical B cell lymphomagenesis model

Vγ9Vδ2 T cells expanded from human PBMCs and adoptively transferred into a murine xenograft model of human lymphomagenesis have potent antitumor effects, even without coadministration of checkpoint inhibitors, likely due to consistently low PD-1 expression on the γδ T cells. Recruitment of γδ T cells to the tumor was followed by decreased expression of PD-L1 and PD-L2 on lymphoma cells.

Inhibition of the B7-H3 immune checkpoint limits tumor growth by enhancing cytotoxic lymphocyte function

Expression of B7-H3 was found in multiple human and murine tumor types, and in tumor-infiltrating dendritic cells and macrophages. Knockout of B7-H3 or inhibition by antibodies reduced tumor growth in mice and was dependent on NK and CD8+ T cells. B7-H3 was found to directly inhibit the activation of NK cells in the tumor microenvironment and its deficiency improved their cytolytic function.

Antigen-capturing nanoparticles improve the abscopal effect and cancer immunotherapy.

To enhance the abscopal effect of radiotherapy, Min et al. designed PLGA-based nanoparticles capable of capturing antigens released by radiolysis of tumor cells and delivering these antigens to antigen-presenting cells. Injected into a tumor prior to radiation, the particles enhanced distant tumor control and provided long-term protection.

Acquired immune resistance follows complete tumor regression without loss of target antigens or IFN-gamma signaling.

Studying the case of a patient who relapsed after a complete radiologic response following TIL therapy, Donia et al. observed evidence for a strong, but ineffective T cell response in the relapsed tumor and multiple defects in antigen-processing machinery (APM) in a cell line from the relapsed tumor, suggesting APM deficiency may be an important mechanism of adaptive resistance. 

Antigen receptor-redirected T cells derived from hematopoietic precursor cells lack expression of the endogenous TCR/CD3 receptor and exhibit specific antitumor capacities.

T-lineage committed cells were isolated from human cord blood hematopoietic progenitor cells, transduced with either a CAR or TCRα/β construct, and expanded. The transduced cells had a mostly naive phenotype and were functional and, importantly, lacked surface-expressed endogenous CD3/TCRα/β complexes, reducing the potential for alloreactivity.

Everything New this Week In...